**Session Date/Time:** 10 Nov 2026 15:30 # [OCM](../wg/ocm.html) ## Summary The Open Cloud Mesh (OCM) Virtual Interim meeting focused on the status and planned updates for the working group's active drafts. The primary discussion centered on `draft-ietf-ocm-open-cloud-mesh`, specifically regarding breaking backward compatibility to fix security vulnerabilities (such as Server-Side Request Forgery), removing forward dependencies on satellite drafts, integrating support for resource collections, and expanding the distributed directory service. The group also discussed timeline adjustments for milestones and plans to request early reviews from related working groups (such as the MLS working group). ## Key Discussion Points ### Document Status Thibault Meunier presented the status using the [Chair slides](https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/interim-2026-ocm-03/materials/slides-interim-2026-ocm-03-sessa-chair-slides-00): - **`draft-ietf-ocm-open-cloud-mesh`**: Currently at version -07. Editors plan to publish version -08 next week following the IETF draft submission freeze. Community reviews are strongly encouraged. - **`draft-ietf-ocm-mls-federated-groups`**: Working group document at version -00. Discussions and MLS coordination are ongoing on the mailing list. - **`draft-ietf-ocm-integration-protocol`**: Working group document at version -00. ### Work Items and Architectural Changes Giuseppe LoPresti presented [Work items for draft-ocm-open-cloud-mesh](https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/interim-2026-ocm-03/materials/slides-interim-2026-ocm-03-sessa-work-items-for-draft-ocm-open-cloud-mesh-00): - **Forward Dependencies**: Editors (Giuseppe LoPresti, Micke Nordin) will ensure `draft-ietf-ocm-open-cloud-mesh` has no forward dependencies on `draft-ietf-ocm-mls-federated-groups` or `draft-ietf-ocm-integration-protocol`, allowing the core document to advance independently. - **Breaking Backward Compatibility (OCM v2 Cleanup)**: - Security reviews identified potential Server-Side Request Forgery (SSRF) risks when implementations combine legacy fallback behaviors (e.g., basic authentication). - Ron Trompert raised concerns regarding breaking backward compatibility for active deployments. - Giuseppe LoPresti and Micke Nordin explained that major platforms (Nextcloud, ownCloud, OpenCloud) are already aligned with modern practices. Breaking compatibility primarily deprecates unsafe legacy practices from 10-year-old draft iterations. Maciej Brzeźniak noted that while Seafile installations exist, long-term OCM adoption effort is focused on modern platforms. - Lisa Dusseault and Thibault Meunier supported making necessary normative cleanups (upgrading `SHOULD` to `MUST` and removing deprecated features) prior to Working Group Last Call (WGLC). - **Collections PR**: - Micke Nordin described the collections feature, which provides resource/collection identifiers to advertise datasets before sharing (useful for connecting repositories to file sync-and-share systems). - Text review was completed by Giuseppe LoPresti and Mahdi Baghbani; remaining work involves verifying OpenAPI YAML envelope definitions. - **Distributed Directory Service**: - Giuseppe LoPresti described expanding Appendix C to allow peer-announced federations via notifications without requiring a central directory server or an immediate MLS dependency. - **Terminology**: To avoid confusion around the term "federation", the group agreed that "federation" should refer specifically to server federations. Micke Nordin and Giuseppe LoPresti discussed using terms such as "distributed group" or `dgroup` in JSON payloads to refer to cross-server user groups. - **Implementation Funding**: Giuseppe LoPresti reported approved funding to support reference implementations through January 2026 for notifications, federated groups, and distributed directory services. ## Decisions and Action Items - **`draft-ietf-ocm-open-cloud-mesh` Cleanup**: Editors will proceed with updating the core specification for version 2 by strengthening requirements (changing `SHOULD` to `MUST` where appropriate) and removing deprecated, insecure practices. - **Dependency Decoupling**: Editors will remove forward references in `draft-ietf-ocm-open-cloud-mesh` to `draft-ietf-ocm-mls-federated-groups` and `draft-ietf-ocm-integration-protocol`. - **OpenAPI Schema Check**: Giuseppe LoPresti will review and finalize the OpenAPI YAML specification updates for the Collections pull request. ## Next Steps - **Draft Publication**: Editors will publish `draft-ietf-ocm-open-cloud-mesh-08` after the submission window reopens. - **Milestone Timeline**: Working Group chairs will adjust the core draft target milestone (moving it from December 2025 to Spring 2026) to accommodate editorial cleanup and community review. - **Cross-WG Review**: Once the updated draft is published, the WG will request an early review of `draft-ietf-ocm-mls-federated-groups` from the Messaging Layer Security (MLS) Working Group, as well as relevant HTTP review for `draft-ietf-ocm-open-cloud-mesh`.